Some 46 percent of renters are uninsured even though renters are more satisfied with their insurance than homeowners, according to a new JD Powers study released today.
Price is the leading driver of the satisfaction gap: price satisfaction is a significant 45 points higher among renters than among homeowners. Satisfaction with insurers is higher among renters than among homeowners (809 vs. 787, respectively, on a 1,000-point scale), the study found.
State Farm captures the largest share of the renter insurance market (26%), followed by Allstate (12%) and USAA (10%).
Customer retention rates with their current insurer are higher among renters who bundle an auto policy (91%) compared to renters who do not bundle an auto policy (67%).
“Many insurance agents focus their time selling high-dollar products, such as auto and homeowners, with higher commissions instead of the average $200 per year renters policy,” said Jeremy Bowler, senior director of the global insurance practice at J.D. Power. “This is shortsighted because agents who satisfy the large renter population today are more likely to retain and service their growing household insurance needs over time” (learn more in the review of SuperMoney).
Rankings | |||
Overall Customer Satisfaction Index Scores | J.D. Power.com Power Circle Ratings | ||
(Based on a 1,000-point scale) | For Consumers | ||
Homeowners Segment | |||
Amica Mutual | 842 | 5 | |
State Farm | 813 | 4 | |
Auto-Owners Insurance | 812 | 4 | |
Erie Insurance | 811 | 4 | |
Automobile Club of Southern California | 808 | 4 | |
Encompass | 798 | 4 | |
American Family | 797 | 4 | |
Progressive | 796 | 4 | |
COUNTRY | 795 | 3 | |
Allstate | 789 | 3 | |
GEICO | 789 | 3 | |
The Hartford | 787 | 3 | |
Homeowners Average | 787 | 3 | |
NCNU Insurance Exchange | 786 | 3 | |
Nationwide | 780 | 3 | |
MetLife | 778 | 3 | |
Safeco | 778 | 3 | |
Automobile Club Group | 776 | 3 | |
CHUBB | 768 | 2 | |
The Hanover | 766 | 2 | |
Farmers | 763 | 2 | |
Liberty Mutual | 762 | 2 | |
Travelers | 756 | 2 | |
__________________________ | |||
USAA* | 894 | 5 | |
*USAA is an insurance provider open only to U.S. military personnel and their families and therefore is not included in the rankings. | |||
Homeowners Segment: Included in the study but not award-eligible due to localized availability and/or not meeting minimum sample requirements are Alfa Insurance, Allied, Cincinnati Insurance, Fireman’s Fund, Homesite, Mercury, North Carolina Farm Bureau, Shelter and Tennessee Farm Bureau. |