Categories: Bedford Hillsblog

Justice Sues S&P; Is It Time to Rethink the Role of Ratings Agencies? | Bedford Hills Real Estate

Most of the time, court cases are manna for journalists. The politicians and corporations we cover aren’t in the habit of dishing out information they don’t want the public to know. But along comes a lawsuit, and the parties are often forced to put a lot of juicy details on the public record. So when the Justice Department yesterday announced a joint federal and state lawsuit against the ratings agency Standard & Poor’s for defrauding investors in the run up to the financial crisis with its overly optimistic ratings of mortgage-related investments, I was excited to see what new dirt the complaint would unearth.

Much to my chagrin, however, the complaint is a fairly mundane read  for the simple fact that we have known for years that the ratings agencies were hamstrung by a fundamental conflict of interest: They are paid by the sellers of securities rather than the buyers. So during the inflation of the real estate bubble in the early 2000s, as investment banks scrambled to package mortgages into complex financial instruments, ratings agencies also scrambled to figure out how to get those investment banks to chose them to rate their securities. What was S&P’s strategy to entice investment banks to pay it rather than its competitors? Rate their securities higher.

The complaint does put this dynamic into sharper relief, as it provides us with the details of conversations, emails, and instant message exchanges that show the evolution of S&P’s ratings philosophy from one focused primarily on accurate

This post was last modified on %s = human-readable time difference 6:19 pm

Robert Paul

Robert is a realtor in Bedford NY. He has been successfully working with buyers and sellers for years. His local area of expertise includes Bedford, Pound Ridge, Armonk, Lewisboro, Chappaqua and Katonah. When you have a local real estate question please call 914-325-5758.

Recent Posts

Out of Sevice with brain injury since November.

Just back out of hospital in early March for home recovery. Therapist coming today.

2 years ago

Existing home sales down 28% | Katonah Real Estate

Sales fell 5.9% from September and 28.4% from one year ago.

2 years ago

Single-Family Housing Contraction Continues | Bedford Hills Real Estate

Housing starts decreased 4.2% to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1.43 million units in…

2 years ago

Closed Median Sale Price in Hudson Valley/NYC Markets Declined by 2.50% in October | Bedford Real Estate

OneKey MLS reported a regional closed median sale price of $585,000, representing a 2.50% decrease…

2 years ago

Building Materials Prices Decline for Second Consecutive Month | Pound Ridge Real Estate

The prices of building materials decreased 0.2% in October

2 years ago

Mortgage rates drop with inflation drop | Bedford Corners Real Estate

Mortgage rates went from 7.37% yesterday to 6.67% as of this writing.

2 years ago

This website uses cookies.